Evangelion Begins by Making Shinji Pilot Before It Explains Anything
SPOILER!
Open →
Shinji reaches
Tokyo-3 expecting to meet the father who abandoned him and instead finds a city under attack. Gendo's first meaningful request is that Shinji pilot
Unit-01.
The series does not wait for Shinji to become brave. He agrees while frightened, untrained and angry because the alternative is watching an injured Rei be sent in his place.
Why it matters
The central fact about Shinji is not that he refuses to pilot. It is that he keeps piloting under conditions that give him very little reason to trust the adults asking him to do it.
Bardiel Makes Refusal Morally Complicated
SPOILER!
Open →
Shinji will not attack
Unit-03 while another pilot may be trapped inside. Gendo responds by activating the
Dummy Plug and makes
Unit-01 destroy the infected Eva anyway.
The pilot is Toji.
Why it matters
Shinji learns that refusing to act does not remove him from the consequences.
NERV can use his Eva without his consent, and his friend can still be the person crushed under its hands.